When it comes to Thanksgiving desserts, one debate always stirs the table: cake or pie? Some families are firmly Team Pie, insisting that Thanksgiving isn’t complete without pumpkin, pecan, or apple pie. Others argue that a beautiful cake deserves a place of honor alongside the turkey. At Happy Hippo Bakery, we say why not both? But let’s have a little fun and break down the case for each.
🥧 The Case for Pie
Pie is the traditional Thanksgiving dessert, and for good reason. Its warm, cozy flavors pair perfectly with the season:
- Pumpkin Pie – Creamy, spiced, and a holiday classic.
- Pecan Pie – Sweet, nutty, and rich with Southern charm.
- Apple Pie – Tart, cinnamon-kissed, and best served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Pies are nostalgic, they remind us of family kitchens, flour-dusted aprons, and the comfort of tradition. They’re also versatile: bake them full-size for sharing, or make minis for easy individual servings.
🎂 The Case for Cake
Cake lovers know that no celebration is complete without a layered showstopper. Cakes bring flair and flexibility to the Thanksgiving dessert table:
- Pumpkin Spice Cake with cream cheese frosting.
- Apple Spice Layer Cake drizzled with caramel.
- Maple Pecan Cake with fluffy buttercream.
Cake has the advantage of feeding a crowd, plus it can be decorated to match the holiday theme. From rustic naked cakes to elegant buttercream designs, cake gives you a centerpiece that’s as beautiful as it is delicious.
🍴 Why Not Both?
Here’s the real secret: you don’t have to choose. Offering both cake and pie ensures every guest finds their favorite. A slice of pumpkin pie for the traditionalists and a piece of spice cake for the sweet-toothed is the best way to please the whole table.
For hosts who don’t want to spend hours in the kitchen, pre-ordering a mix of desserts makes entertaining stress-free. Let us handle the baking so you can focus on making memories.
🦃 Pre-Order Your Thanksgiving Desserts
Whether your family leans Team Cake, Team Pie, or both, we’ve got you covered. Our Thanksgiving menu includes all the fall classics (pumpkin, apple, and pecan pies) along with seasonal cakes that bring something extra special to your holiday table.
📅 Pre-ordering is open now for Thanksgiving week! Be sure to reserve your desserts early to guarantee availability. Local pickup in Hutto, TX.